Searching for an engagement ring that will make her say “Yes!” with joy?
Choosing a trusted retailer from one of the best places to buy engagement rings ensures you receive a high-quality, stunning piece at an affordable price — an investment that’s not only meaningful but also made to last a lifetime.
To simplify your search, we’ve evaluated the leading retailers, with special attention given to the top-ranked option: Rare Carat, a one-stop destination for everything related to diamonds, ring settings, and more.
1. Rare Carat
With the option to choose your own diamond type and ring setting, Rare Carat has become a go-to destination for diamond engagement rings. Their unbeatable prices can help you save up to 40% compared to the next five retailers featured here.
Reasons to choose Rare Carat:
- Exceptional offers and services, including a 100% money-back guarantee and free insured shipping
- Free 30-day returns and 90-day resizing, ensuring you’re completely satisfied with your ring
- 5-star ratings on Trustpilot and Google — the highest among the retailers on this list
2. Zales
Zales’ recent expansion of its lab grown diamond collection has attracted more customers to choose this brand for engagement rings. However, their prices tend to be higher than Rare Carat’s offerings.
Reasons to choose Zales:
- A trusted and well-established retailer, perfect for seamless online and in-store experiences
- Optional as well as complimentary lifetime protection plans for your engagement ring
- Flexible payment options to suit your budget
3. Brilliant Earth
With Brilliant Earth, you can find the perfect engagement ring — ethically sourced and sustainably crafted. While their prices are higher than Rare Carat’s, their multiple discounts and offers can help you choose a ring that fits both your preferences and budget.
Reasons to choose Brilliant Earth:
- Free 30-day returns & exchanges, plus free 60-day resizing for complete satisfaction
- User-friendly online platform with exclusive, add-on customer benefits
- Free shipping both ways for hassle-free engagement ring adjustments
4. Tiffany
Tiffany isn’t just a brand — it is a symbol of luxury and elegance. However, Tiffany engagement rings come at a premium price. If you want that same luxury and elegance at a more affordable price, Rare Carat offers excellent alternatives.
Reasons to choose Tiffany:
- An easy-to-navigate online platform ensures a smooth engagement ring shopping experience
- Engagement rings priced under $75,000 are eligible for a 30-day return from the purchase date
- Offers many useful personalized customer services
5. Kay
Are you discouraged by Kay’s lower Trustpilot and Google ratings compared to Rare Carat? While their higher prices may contribute to this, you can balance off the cost by taking advantage of Kay’s frequent sales and attractive promotions, especially during major shopping seasons for engagement rings.
Reasons to choose Kay:
- Flexible financing options help you find budget-friendly pieces
- A 30-day return window from the shipment date ensures your satisfaction with the purchase
- Excellent customer service is available both online and in-store
Blue Nile
This easy-to-navigate online platform allows customers to choose a diamond engagement ring based on their preferences (cut, clarity, color, and carat) with ease. However, the prices of Blue Nile products tend to be higher than most retailers, including this list’s top-ranked Rare Carat.
Reasons to choose Blue Nile:
- Offers the ease to design your own engagement ring with a 30-day return policy
- An impressive 4.1 rating on Trustpilot and Google (Rare Carat: 5/5 stars)
- Provides 24/7 customer service for a worry-free shopping experience
Conclusion: Why is Rare Carat top-ranking
Each retailer mentioned in the above list offers its own set of advantageous services and benefits. But Rare Carat’s consistent dedication to providing the best quality at the most affordable prices has helped the brand maintain its impressive 5-star ratings on Trustpilot and Google. So, if you’re searching for the perfect engagement ring that meets all your specific preferences and budget requirements, look no further than Rare Carat.
##
